Monday, January 7, 2013

City Burns Cash and Opportunity with Demolition of Powell Square



Last Thursday, the City of St. Louis commenced demolition of the Powell Square Building at 217 Cedar Street in Chouteau's Landing south of the Arch grounds. As the video above from KMOV Channel 4 points out, the City hired the demolition contractor for the sum of $265,000.00 of taxpayer money to demolish the building and will bill Steve Murphy, the buildings owner in hopes of recouping the cash. If Murphy does not (or cannot) pay, the City will add the sum to his tax bill. If the amount is not paid in 3 years, then the City will sell the vacant property at a courthouse auction. If no one bids, then the City ends up with the vacant land... because there is apparently a coming shortage of City owned vacant land!

First, a little history of Powell Square:

The Powell Square Building was constructed in 1916 as the headquarters for the John T. Milliken Pharmaceutical and Absorbent Cotton Plant. When Mr. Milliken died from pneumonia three years later, he was said to be the richest man in St. Louis. The buildings architect was William Wedemeyer, who's architectural firm is the predecessor of Wedemeyer-Cernick-Corrubia, which still operates today.

The Milliken Pharmaceutical and Absorbent Cotton Plant was differentiated from most industrial buildings in that it was constructed completely of reinforced concrete, with no brick infills and almost no ornamentation whatsoever. This was particularly unusual in St. Louis, a city that was so dominated by brick masonry construction. The Milliken building was preceded only by the Luyties Homeopathic Pharmaceutical Building at 4200 Laclede a year earlier in 1915 as the first building constructed in St. Louis entirely of reinforced concrete. The crenelated all-concrete addition to the Crumden-Martin complex by tom Barnett, located kitty corner to the Milliken building at 2nd & Cedar, would be built four years later in 1920.


Fulton Bag Factory St. Louis
In 1926, the building was purchased by the Fulton Bag and Cotton Mill Company. The transaction was unusual in that as part of Fulton Bag's payment for the building on Cedar, their former building at 12 South Seventh Street was transferred to Milliken Pharmaceutical, who moved into the building and remained for several years. The building on South Seventh still stands and was renovated several years as the Fulton Bag Lofts. Photo above ca. 1930 from the Georgia Institute of Technology.

In 1952 Fulton Bag added the truck dock addition to the east side of the building, also completely constructed of formed concrete. in 1956, Fulton Bag moved to a new building constructed for the company on Gustine Avenue. General Fibre Company purchased the former Milliken plant in 1957 and occupied the building for several years. Between that time and 2001, the building had numerous owners/tenants, one of which was the Dan Powell Co. Inc., which gave the building its current name Powell Square.

Powell Square 2003 04
The formed concrete entrance surround with its low sloped pediment was the only portion of the building that could be considered ornamented.

Powell Square 2003 03
In 2001 Steve Murphy, a lawyer and partner at the firm Devereaux Murphy in Clayton, purchased the Powell Square building as part of a larger assemblage of buildings in Chouteau's Landing and along South Fourth Street on the western edge of the district. Murphy's acquisitions included the Crumden-Martin warehouse #5 which suffered from a fire in December 2011 that damaged the roof and upper two floors.

Murphy formed Chivvis Development to begin the re-development of the buildings along South Fourth Street to create a gateway to larger developments east of I-55. He succeeded in completing renovations of a 2-story building at 756 South Fourth Street and a 3-story building at 904-908 South Fourth Street, which was shortened by the construction of the MacAurthur Bridge between 1909 and 1917.

Powell Square 2003 01
Murphy began advertising the Powell Square for lease as white-box space suitable for office, studio or production space. Below is a portion of a brochure from Hilliker Corporation promoting the building. The claim that the property was "currently under complete renovation" were a bit pre-mature. Photos above from 2003.

Powell Square 2005 Hilliker Brochure


Torpedo Factory Art Center 01
On a trip to Alexandria, Murphy and his wife visited the Torpedo Factory Art Center and were immediately inspired to bring the idea back to St. Louis, and thus was born the idea for the Chouteau's Landing Art Center (CLAC). The Powell Square building seemed a perfect fit for the concept which includes artist studios available for rent and open to the public, galleries, art classes, event space rental and more. I had the pleasure of working with Murphy as the architect for of this project with ebersoldt + associates architecture in 2008 & 2009. Below were the conceptual plans for the renovation.

CLAC 1st floor 010509
The first floor of the CLAC would have contained galleries, a large open event space, a glass blowing studio, a cafe and a small art supply store. The exterior would have included a sculpture terrace and garden. A separate small foundry building and additional public parking would have bee built north of the adjacent railroad trestle. The basement would have had accessible parking, parking for some artist tenants and staff as well as storage.

CLAC 2nd floor 010509
The second floor would have included classroom studios for ceramics, painting, fiber, jewelry, children's art, a small gift shop, artist studios open to the public, as well as a small terrace and green rooftop sculpture garden atop the 1952 addition.

CLAC 3rd floor 010509
Murphy had secured a letter of intent from the International Photography Hall of Fame to occupy a large tenant space on the third floor. The IPHF is a museum currently located in Oklahoma City that has an extensive permanent collection of photographic images from notable photographers, a collection of historic photographic equipment and a library. The IPHF also hosts special exhibitions focusing on the art and science of photography. The IPHF is still moving to St. Louis, and will be opening later this year in Grand Center. The third floor of the CLAC would have also included a digital studio and more artist studios open to the public.

CLAC 4th floor 010509
The fourth floor would have contained offices for the CLAC, rental artist studio spaces that would only be open to the public on a periodic basis and a banquet kitchen to serve the event spaces.

CLAC 5th floor 010509
The fifth floor for the CLAC would have been devoted to event space opening to rooftop terraces with panoramic views of Downtown and the river. 

The Murphy's were very excited to bring this type of facility to Chouteau's Landing. They saw this project as being the gateway and the draw for ordinary people to finally discover the hidden gem that is Chouteau's Landing, and planned further developments including artist live-work lofts as well as traditional loft condos and apartments in additional buildings including Crumden-Martin #5. They were aware that overcoming the urban planning disasters that had isolated this district would be difficult at best, but we all were confident that locating the CLAC in the very visible Powell Square building could be a key factor in bringing people to Chouteau's Landing.

While a much smaller facility, the Foundry Art Center exists in St. Charles just north of the historic downtown shopping district, and components of the concept can be found at Craft Alliance and Third Degree Glass, no such facility of this scale bringing all of these ingredients together exists in the St. Louis area. 

Google Earth
These were some initial concept renderings for the exterior of the building.

CLAC rendering Cedar Street
We did several studies with one color, combinations of color and application of the CLAC logo but were not overly thrilled with most of them. Very aware of the buildings use as a canvas for street artists, we also considered the possibility for commissioning one or possible several artists to apply their handiwork to various portions of the building.  This idea would have had to have been carefully handled as we were also aware that some considered this aspect of the building to be a notorious and very visible eyesore.

CLAC exterior color concept

While the idea for the Chouteau's Landing Art Center was great, the timing however could not have been much worse. With the financial crash of 2008, we heard that Murphy had lost a good amount of personal equity, but he continued to try to make the project work. By 2009, the lending market had evaporated and finding someone to fund a project  of this size without guaranteed revenues was nearly impossible. By the end of 2009, it was obvious that the CLAC was dead.
IMG_1592
Beyond financial issues, one of Murphy's major mistakes with Powell Square was pre-maturely removing all of the buildings original windows. To many, this made the building look like an eyesore. It also made the historic structure much more difficult to have listed on the National Register of Historic Places, which would have made a renovation eligible for historic tax credits. An initial eligibility assessment was done, but turned down due to the loss of historic integrity. The building could have likely been included as a contributing element to a larger historic district encompassing much of Chouteau's Landing, but unfortunately this was not pursued.

Throughout the development process, the City of St. Louis was pressuring murphy to do something to improve the appearance of the building. It seemed obvious that this was largely due to the buildings prominent visibility to people coming into St. Louis or leaving across the PSB and passing the building on I-55. At one point, the City seemed poised to assist Murphy with an exterior clean-up of the building, but apparently the money never came through. Three years later though, the City condemned the building and seems to have no problem burning $265,000 to demolish it. 


In 2010, artist Peat Wollaeger painted a large "I heart STL" on one of the more visible sections of the building. He had a vision that instead of cleaning the building, it could become an artists colony like the graffiti covered 5 Pointz Art Center in New York City. Here is the full story from the Post-Dispatch. This plan unfortunately never took off.

This fall, the Powell Square building could have found a new alternative lease on life with an idea from Vincent Stemmler to turn the building into a vertical farm. This idea apparently had Murphy's support, and was trying to gain funding on Rally St. Louis. Even as the City of St. Louis is finalizing a City-wide sustainability plan which calls for reducing demolitions and supporting sustainable practice, which this certainly would have been, they went ahead with demolition of Powell Square. 

This also begs the question: Does every old industrial or office building need to have a $20 million+ rehabilitation to be considered a successful redevelopment? If so, then we should expect to lose many more of these buildings in the future as well as end up with a lot more vacant land. Is this a better "welcome to St. Louis"?

7 comments:

Ann said...

I am SO sad about Powell Square and even more sad that I never got the guts to go visit.

What a fascinating history - I had no idea it had all these plans and they all disappeared.

nzorach said...

Certainly terrible that the city spent taxpayer money to demolish the building, but worse than that is our weak private sector that, with all of our fortune 100 companies and wealthy elite, can't muster the capital to make this kind of project a profitable reality.

Definitely true that it doesn't need to be a huge, bazillion-dollar project, but the persistent lament over demolition is coupled with lethargy as far as considering real development options. The notion that there just "isn't" money to do projects is preposterous.

Nat Zorach

Vanishing STL said...

Nat, Very good point about about the the notion of financing not being available. While in late 2008, 2009 through at least 2011 conventional financing through a bank was nearly impossible to secure, by last year however, while the taps have not re-opened to pre-crash status, it seems that more projects were being funded again and this should continue.

More importantly, it should be noted that during this same period, the St. Louis Art Museum managed to raise $130 million in private donations to make the soon to open expansion happen. With the right kind of fundraising and support from the areas wealthy corporations and individuals, the Chouteau's Landing Art Center would have been completed and open by now.

دردشة ومنتديات عراقنا said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Brianbobcat said...

I live in Chicago, and it really sucks to read about Saint Louis officials and their almost complete disregard for historic structures. While I'm not so sure that this building is what many would deem "historic", it clearly was still structurally sound, and had great potential, so if the only reason to tear it down was the "eyesore" that it was entering Saint Louis, that's a terrible excuse. Chicago has demolished more than it's fair share of historic structures, but I also know I'm fortunate for us having as many historic buildings both in our downtown and in the outlying neighborhoods. Some in Chicago that are endanger include the Saint Boniface Church, St. Laurence Church at 1300 E. 72nd St., including a building at the edge of Midway Airport that is in great structural condition but that the city wants to remove because of "security concerns". The city has also let numerous buildings in it's possession crumble and fall, like the sister of the building next to Midway: http://www.wbez.org/blog/lee-bey/2012-02-02/79th-street-architecture-lost-when-walls-came-tumbling-down-96041

Since I'm from Chicago but check out your blog, a couple good ones about Chicago include: http://www.wbez.org/blogs/lee-bey
http://forgottenchicago.com and
http://featuresblogs.chicagotribune.com/theskyline/2012/01/a-letter-to-cityscapes-a-neighborhood-gem-near-midway-airport-is-threatened-with-demolition.html, although that last one is about Chicago buildings as a whole, so it covers old, as in the link, and new structures.

Hopefully people begin to realize that if you tear down every building in your downtown, all you're going to be left with are a lot of empty lots and no buildings. Ask Detroit what that's like.

Ryan Walters said...

In April, 2011, myself and a fellow photographer ventured into Powell Square in the very early morning hours. We had nothing but our cameras and wits with us, seeking to better understand the soul of such a prominent vacant building, and Powell Square didn't let us down. It had an inspiring beauty all its own. I'm so saddened to learn of its demise...

Photos here: http://blog.rwvisuals.com/rwv/powell-square.html

I have many more, and will soon publish them as well. I'm happy to donate them if there's any interest.

Ryan Walters

Josh the Intern said...

to the North, St. Louis Arch and the Old Cathedral, downtown skyscrapers and Busch Stadium. To the South... yeesh, a vandalized warehouse on prominent land and railroad tracks.

South of 40 is not the most glamorous looking area to begin with, but the Powell Square building stood out like trumpet player witht he wrong sheet music. Thank God the arch was to the right of people driving in from Illinois as it probably distracted many from that building.

That being said, it really is a shame no one was able to do anything to make it better. I really don't know if anything really could have made it look better (unless they pulled off what the Sheraton downtown was able to accomplish.

Lastly, I get that the building could have been used for many purposes, but I can't help but think the Art Center deserves a new, unique, and almost flamboyant building to encompass what is going on in the building. The phrase "thinking outside of the box" comes to mind. It's the difference in a textile manufacturing building and a design studio.